If you've not seen the viral video of two horses boarding a DDOT bus through the front door, walking through and exiting through the back door, here it is. It's DDOT bus #1728, running west along 7 Mile. This trip takes place on a Saturday around 5pm.

Unfortunately, most of the discourse around Bus Horse completely ignores one of the key parties1 affected by this incident: people riding DDOT, who are using the bus to head home, get to work, see friends, etc.

So, I thought it would be interesting to take a look at this trip and how bus #1728 stuck to the schedule along its route, and how the ~2.5 minutes that it took for the horses to board/exit possibly affected riders who were riding bus #1728 further down the line, which runs from Mack and Moross all the way to the Old Redford Meijer, which is about a 20 mile trip. Here are the key findings:

  • Bus #1728 is more or less on time when it arrives at 7 Mile and Strasburg, where the riders and horses are waiting.

  • The stop takes around 2.5 minutes, so when bus #1728 leaves Strasburg, it's running about 3 minutes late.

  • Bus #1728 is delayed a bit more at Hoover; it waits another 3 minutes for riders of the northbound 13 Conner bus to make a connection with bus #1728.

  • Bus #1728's adherence to the printed schedule never recovers from these two delays; it remains at least 5 minutes late for the rest of the trip, peaking at 10 minutes late.

Worse, bus #1728 running on this 5-to-10 minute delay means that riders heading west on 7 Mile on this trip likely missed two key transfers:

  • Bus #1728 riders probably missed their connection to the southbound 4 Woodward bus; there was only ~2 minutes to make the connection across one of the largest intersections in the city, and the southbound Woodward bus doesn't appear to wait for them. The next southbound Woodward bus doesn't arrive for another 15 minutes.

  • Bus #1728 riders definitely missed their connection to the southbound 10 Greenfield bus; that bus leaves 7 Mile & Greenfield about 30 seconds before bus #1728 arrives. The next southbound Greenfield doesn't arrive for another 28 minutes.

Here's the bus trip data in an interactive animation, so you can get a better idea of the overall journey.

At the risk of being simplistic: sticking to the schedule matters. A few minutes at one stop doesn't sound like much. But those few minutes turn into 15- and 28-minute waits further along in the journey, and that should be an unacceptable outcome for a completely pointless delay.

Real-time trip data2 can help keep riders informed about delays in progress, but it's no substitute for being able to travel across town predictably on the published schedule, or for buses that come often enough that missing one isn't a big deal (which DDOT is slowly working towards, but we're still quite far from, especially on weekends).

So yes, the whole internet loves Bus Horse (and on some level, in the part of my brain that doesn't remember waiting half an hour for a missed transfer, I do too). But given the choice between the whimsical serendipity of Bus Horse and the pleasantly boring bus ride where riders make their transfers, we should choose the latter every time.